INTRODUCTION - “OF ALL TYRANNIES, A TYRANNY SINCERELY EXERCISED FOR THE GOOD OF ITS VICTIMS MAY BE THE MOST OPPRESSIVE.” — C.S. LEWIS
Based on my openly stated support of biology, the Constitution, and federal law, a charge of “conduct unbecoming” was brought against me by a SAG-AFTRA member we’ll call Mr. Zero. The charge was brought to the Union with the goal to have me found guilty, and for the Union to remove me from my position as National Board member representing Portland, a seat I have held for 38 years, and one from which I was retiring in 18 months.
SAG-AFTRA then became judge and jury over an accusation that questions the very basis of our democracy.
This essay is my defense of the foundation upon which our Union should stand.
I presented this treatise to SAG-AFTRA’s Disciplinary Committee on Wednesday, January 21st, in a 2+ hour putative trial where I stood accused of transphobia, and as a transphobe was thus unable to fairly represent the members in Portland Oregon. I read this piece to the Committee generally as presented here, with some edits and additions.
The Committee took the “evidence” of my transphobia and my defense under advisement, and adjourned on the 21st to deliberate. On January 28th, it rendered a verdict: “After full consideration of the evidence and arguments presented, and after careful deliberation, the Disciplinary Committee finds that there was insufficient evidence presented to establish ‘serious misconduct’ on the part of Ms. McDonald-Lewis that would warrant a recommendation for removal from the National Board pursuing to article XVII.C. This matter is now deemed concluded and closed.”
So why publish this essay at all, given that I prevailed?
First, as a free-speech defense, perhaps it can be of service to others similarly attacked. Secondly, to turn the prosecution into the defendant: Should SAG-AFTRA have even considered this charge, and what dark forces compelled it to do so? Thirdly, to demonstrate that attempting to silence people like you and I will just make us louder.
But as time is in short supply for everyone, here is a summary of the piece provided by ChatGPT, to help you sort out if the essay can be useful to you:
“In Stand and Deliver, Mary McDonald-Lewis presents a first-person defense against a ‘conduct unbecoming’ charge brought within SAG-AFTRA, arguing that the complaint represents not professional misconduct but a politically motivated attempt to suppress lawful speech. Grounded in constitutional principles, federal labor law, and union governance rules, the essay contends that ideological conformity—rather than member protection—has become an unofficial enforcement mechanism within a captured institution.
McDonald-Lewis traces how her publicly stated views on sex-based rights, biology, and free expression triggered a formal complaint process that, she argues, violates both due process and the union’s stated mission. She situates her experience within a broader cultural and institutional shift in which dissent is reframed as harm, procedural safeguards are weakened, and ‘safety’ is invoked to justify censorship.
The essay further asserts that unions, as quasi-governmental bodies with significant power over members’ livelihoods, bear heightened responsibility to protect viewpoint neutrality and lawful expression. By documenting procedural irregularities, rhetorical distortions, and the weaponization of internal disciplinary mechanisms, McDonald-Lewis argues that the true ‘conduct unbecoming’ lies in the abandonment of democratic norms and member representation.
Ultimately, Stand and Deliver is both a personal defense and a warning: When institutions designed to protect workers instead enforce ideological obedience, they erode trust, chill speech, and undermine the very solidarity they claim to uphold.”
The defense:
ACT ONE – “WELCOME, IN THE LION’S NAME. COME FURTHER UP AND FURTHER IN.” – C.S. Lewis
Hello, everyone. Hi Mr. Zero, hello staff, greetings to my brothers and sisters on the Disciplinary Committee, and of course, salutations to SAG-AFTRA as a whole.
The quote I just read to you, as with all quotes heading up this essay’s sections and concluding the piece, are by C.S. Lewis, whose book, Mere Christianity, I am reading just now.
I want to begin by thanking Mr. Zero, the Committee and staff, the Union, and God for the opportunity to be with you here today. I am, if not pleased, energized at the chance to speak to you about my favorite subject, which I’ll be delving into deeply as we go along.
I’m given to understand that as the defendant, I have three opportunities to speak: Act One is this, my opening remarks; Act Two is my response to the charge of “conduct unbecoming” brought against me by Mr. Zero; and the Third Act contains my concluding thoughts.
Before the curtain formally rises on Act One, then, a little housekeeping. What you are hearing now, and everything you will hear from me today, comes from an essay I have written about this hearing: about the charge and why it ought not to stand, why it was allowed to be brought to begin with, and the cost of this kind of political assault, to me, to the Union, and to our country.
This essay follows on three pieces I’ve written along similar lines for FAIR, the Foundation Against Intolerance and Racism, and which, I’m humbled to say, have been well-received. It may be that this essay will be published with FAIR; or it might be posted to Doxie Thoughts, my own Substack. It also includes generous links to outside material supporting each of my arguments.
I’m a public speaker on this topic as well, my latest being The Toll of Cancellation on the Human Spirit, and this essay – about this charge and its cost – will also become material for future talks.
Finally: Some of you may recall that my father, Dr. James Ford Lewis, was a Unitarian minister, a breathtakingly good speaker and orator of the nineteenth-century style. Many of his sermons found their way into books, especially those about the March to Montgomery: He was there in Selma, Alabama with Dr. King. (And I was there for the 50th Anniversary of the Crossing of the Edmund Pettus Bridge, in his memory.) Dad was often asked for copies of his sermons, which he happily obliged. I’m not the writer my father was, but I will gladly share this essay with anyone requesting it.

Now let me wrap up Act One with what you can expect in Act Two.
First, we’re going to get clear on what is really at stake here, and it has nothing to do with how Mr. Zero, this committee, the staff, the Union or I feel about any particular thing, including, specific to this concern, the question of transgenderism.
Then we’re going to visit the US Constitution and a founding father; after this, the Union’s Constitution, and then we’ll spend a little time with the Landrum-Griffin Act.
I’ll weave in some current events for illustrative purposes, before moving on to Shakespeare – to Cordelia and her dad, King Lear, in particular.
Though the Bard is a tough act to follow, I’ll come along afterwards with the backstory of my personal experience with the homegrown political violence Portland has gotten so good at around this issue, and touch upon my essays on the subject.
And as this is an interrogation, I’ll then probe the reasons why the Union saw fit to support this charge against me, and offer a few ideas there.
I think that about covers where we are going to go in the Second Act.
In the Third Act, I’ll close with an exhortation or two in favor of what is best about this flawed and magnificent place, and how instead of propping up spurious, anti-American charge like this, we should be defending the freedoms we were given, which are under assault daily, more from within than without; and which are more fragile than we know.
And finally the Bible will be brought to bear on the conversation, with words that serve as rod and staff for me as I stand upon the rock of my conviction about – well, not about this charge, for it is small and meaningless in comparison to the great and good ideas it seeks to undermine – but about the shimmering promise made to us here in America, and about keeping that flame alive.
I am devoted to the process we are engaged in today, my friends. I am committed to see it through with honor, with truth, with fearlessness, and with the hope that my words, no matter what the Committee does in response, will ring and echo and inspire.
ACT TWO - “TRUTH IS LIKE A LION; YOU DON’T HAVE TO DEFEND IT. LET IT LOOSE, AND IT WILL DEFEND ITSELF.” – C.S. Lewis
The charge against me, as well as I can understand it, is that, given what Mr. Zero thinks I think about people who describe themselves as “transgender,” I am not fit to serve as a leader in Portland as SAG-AFTRA’s National Board member.
There are a few flaws in his reasoning, I believe. First, Mr. Zero has no clear understanding of what I think. No man can ever really know what another man thinks, the whole of it and the why of it.
Second, the charge relies on the presumption that he has a right to know what I think, inasmuch as that’s possible – that he has a right to know the workings of my mind and what is harbored in my heart. I dispute that notion: my thoughts are my own, and no others, just as his, and all of yours, are too. We assume the current fashion of pawing through the mind of a colleague or employee or student or fellow church member, like a second story man paws through the underwear drawer seeking jewelry and cash, is a better one than the old-fashioned value of leaving each man alone, to build, tear down, and re-build his inner world and live within it as he sees fit.
That we have a ghastly lack of privacy now does not mean we must feed it, twitching like Mrs. Kravitz at her curtains. Does not mean that respect for the individual isn’t far superior to serving as the neighborhood Peeping Tom, despite the virtue points so many seek from the dirty act, those meaningless accolades tossed like cheap throws at Mardi Gras.
Third, whatever I believe – in fact whatever any person or any organization believes – is the unique purview of that individual or organization, and we all are free to believe, and to express those beliefs, in any way we see fit in the course of our endeavors.
So you see, this is not about my opinion about people who describe themselves as transgender, or about my feelings about pistachio ice cream, which I love, or horror movies, which I hate. It is about my right to both have, and express, these feelings. And further, to never be forced to believe, or express, anything I do not believe.
This is about freedom of speech, you see, and about freedom from compelled speech.
Which brings us to the US Constitution and these golden words: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.”
It was James Madison, principally, who penned into existence the most astonishing experiment in governance the world has ever seen. In 1791 he wrote in the National Gazette that “Public opinion sets bounds to every government, and is the real sovereign in every free one.” It was key, he wrote, to ensure “a general intercourse of sentiments.”
Madison understood that it was the people, informed and able to speak their mind without restriction, who were going to be responsible for building the new America. And freedom of speech lay at the heart of that project.
To assault free speech is to assault democracy itself. It is to assault we, the people responsible for caring for it, too.
Now, in the case of governmental prosecution of a speech question, or an employer’s pursuit of same, factors including time, place, or manner of speech come into play. However, as a labor union, SAG-AFTRA is a 501(c)(5), and I am a volunteer within it, which, if not absolute, casts doubt upon the wisdom of “firing” me for exercising my right to free speech.
A First Amendment Law Review from the UNC School of Law, in whose shadow I now practically live, concluded that:
“Federal courts that have encountered the issue of whether a volunteer is shielded from retaliation based on protected speech under the First Amendment have consistently determined that the reach of a First Amendment retaliation claim extends to volunteers. ... The key inquiry is whether volunteer status is the type of governmental benefit or privilege the deprivation of which triggers First Amendment scrutiny. Despite arguments to the contrary, federal courts have answered the latter question in the affirmative. It is anticipated that other federal courts that decide the issue, including the United States Supreme Court, will likely, and should, continue the pattern and decide that volunteers are protected from retaliation based on the exercise of their First Amendment rights.” (Take One Step Forward: Federal Courts Continue to Find That Volunteers are Shielded from Retaliation Based on Protected Speech Under the First Amendment)
Let’s look at SAG-AFTRA’s own Constitution, which states:
“Article XVI (16). Non-liability for Unauthorized Acts The Union and any of its affiliated Locals shall not be liable for the acts or conduct of any of their officers, employees or representatives that are outside the scope of their authority, unless expressly authorized in writing by the National Board.”
And as a trade labor union, the Landrum-Griffin Act applies:
This act was formed in 1959 (officially it’s called the Labor-Management Reporting and Disclosure Act), and it’s a U.S. law designed to combat corruption and promote democracy within labor unions by protecting members’ rights, mandating financial transparency, and regulating union elections and leadership. It established a “Bill of Rights” for union members, ensuring free speech and fair participation, while requiring reporting of financial activities, setting election standards, and placing limits on certain union practices like secondary boycotts. This was all in response to 1950s hearings exposing union misconduct.
There are a lot of important provisions, but for our purposes, let’s focus on that Bill of Rights, which in summation, for all union members, “Guarantees members’ rights to free speech, assembly, and voting in union elections, as well as protection against unfair discipline.”
Now let’s get specific. In the Act, under:
A. Protection from union discipline for personal conduct
You will find it provides, under:
Title I (the “Bill of Rights of Members of Labor Organizations”)
Union members have rights to:
• Free speech and assembly within the union
• Participate in union affairs
• Due process before being disciplined
And this bit might be worth making note of:
A union cannot discipline or expel a member for purely personal conduct that:
• Is not related to union duties, and
• Does not interfere with the union’s legitimate institutional interests
The key point, for our purposes here today is, that if an action is personal (outside union roles, meetings, or representation), the union generally cannot punish the member under the LMRDA.
I’m fairly confident that my speech is protected here, and that’s a good thing... but it’s an even better thing that all speech is protected – even speech I hate. For example,
Just this week, activist journalist Don Lemon and a mob disrupted a Baptist church service at Cities Church in St. Paul, the pack screaming and chanting and terrifying the children there because it was suspected that the pastor failed to meet Antifa’s purity test.
Now, a quick aside, this particular exercise may violate the FACE Act, which is the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act of 1994, a U.S. federal law making it illegal to use force, threats, or physical obstruction to prevent people from obtaining or providing reproductive health services or exercising religious freedom at places of worship.
[Nota bene: Days after this event, Lemon was arrested with the FACE Act and the Ku Klux Klan Act of 1871 cited as violations.]
So perhaps this was free speech in action; or perhaps it was, in keeping with the Marxist playbook, a deeply anti-Christian act, allied with this group’s support of Hamas and other official terrorist organizations. But all this is a question for the courts to resolve as they interrogate, as we are doing here, the limits of the First Amendment.
It’s complicated, you see? And awkward and uncomfortable and a Goddamned miracle. As Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States Anthony Kennedy said, “The First Amendment is often inconvenient. But that is beside the point. Inconvenience does not absolve the government of its obligation to tolerate speech.”
Another example: When Governor Walz calls the Vice President a white supremacist in a press conference, it doesn’t matter whether Mr. Zero, this committee, or this union believes Vice President Vance is, or if I believe he isn’t. Walz has the freedom to express his opinion, regardless of what some might guess at as his objective, or his sincerity.
Or how about when Mayor Jacob Frey tells ICE to “...get the fuck out of Minneapolis”?
Again, it’s not important whether Mr. Zero thinks ICE should get the fuck out, or if this committee or this union thinks ICE should get the fuck out. It doesn’t matter if I think the mayor’s approach is cynical, vulgar, and wickedly designed to create more chaos, division and destruction. These are all differing, passionate beliefs that Mr. Zero, this committee, this union as a culture, and I all hold.
And as such, we must hold space for Frey’s expression, as gleeful, or as grim, as it might make us feel.
Free speech is funny that way, you see. As Salmon Rushdie, an artist we all agree has fought with his very life to protect this right said, “What is freedom of expression? Without the freedom to offend, it ceases to exist.” He called it “the whole thing, the whole ball game. Free speech is life itself.” And Noam Chomsky concurs: “If we don’t believe in freedom of expression for people we despise, we don’t believe in it at all.”
You’ll forgive me if I’d rather stand on the precept as argued by these men, than bow down to passing political outrage dressed in shabby virtue.
Before we leave this subject, let’s pause for a moment to examine the difference between “free speech” and “hate speech” in light of this charge. We need to recognize that, whatever the law says or doesn’t say, an agenda-driven business, organization or individual could try to twist what is free speech into something possible to bring pain to the speaker, or writer. The problem there is, according to the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, or FIRE, “in the United States, hateful speech is fully protected by the First Amendment. There’s no ‘hate speech versus free speech’ debate raging in our nation’s judiciary. Nor is there a balancing test, an exemption, or a special constitutional provision allowing the government to prohibit it - hateful speech is categorically protected in our nation, including at public colleges and universities, and that’s not changing anytime soon.”
There are some restrictions. Speech that incites to lawless action, threatens bodily harm, or causes a breach of the peace falls out of free speech. (Many social media posts directed at me meet this test.) But hurdles remain. A key problem with regulating hate speech, as free-speech scholars such as Nadine Strossen have identified, is that it remains “difficult, if not impossible, to define exactly what constitutes hate speech. ... Strossen writes in her book, Hate: Why We Should Resist It with Free Speech, Not Censorship, that ‘the term “hate speech” is not a legal term of art, with a specific definition; rather it is deployed to stigmatize and to suppress widely varying expression.’” And even then, the question of whether anyone accused of hate speech may be subjected to retaliation by an individual or organization without failing in the courts has been answered in many cases, and would be answered here, in the negative.
It’s going to be a stretch for the Disciplinary Committee to conclude my free speech is hate speech, I think.
Despite the clarification that this charge has nothing to do with anything other than free speech, there is still the near-irresistible impulse to ask, to pry, “But what do you actually think about this or that? About pistachio ice cream, or horror films?” I get it – it’s human nature, and it’s what this committee may mistakenly believe this interrogation is about. As someone tormented by Portland thugs for well past a half decade – more on that in a bit – I long ago began a practice taught me by Cordelia in King Lear. When Daddy Lear is divvying up his vast lands into three portions, he uses his daughters’ declarations of love to determine who gets what. Well, as we know, Regan and Goneril are delighted to flatter their father and gain their patch, much to his later dismay.
Cordelia answers quite differently, though. When Lear pries, just like so many do today, to know what she thinks and why, she replies simply “Nothing, my lord.” “Nothing!” the King exclaims, astonished, the second of 34 times the word is used in the play. Cordelia repeats it: “Nothing.” Finally she is forced to expand, but in essence to only say “I love your majesty/According to my bond; nor more nor less.”
Cordelia is the only one telling the truth here: Her father should know, through his lifelong association with her, who she is and how she feels. But his agenda, like the agenda of so many, blinds him to this fact – eventually literally – and she dies for it.
I’m with Cordelia on this one, sisters and brothers. Either you know me or you don’t: either you don’t need to ask, or you wouldn’t believe me if I told you. So I will not answer any specific questions about my beliefs. First, they are not your business, second, I have the right to freely hold and express them, third, submitting to this kind of oppression is as much an attack upon the Union and the country as it is upon me, and I will not allow it.
I will say, “Nothing.”
I mentioned that I have some time before the mast facing down domestic terror in Portland, which has orbited, at least in part, around the subject that ostensibly brought us here today.
Because I refused to declare my pronouns in written and spoken communications, I was fired as dialect coach from Portland’s largest Equity houses, where I coached over 60 plays to stellar reviews. I lost work at every other theater in Oregon immediately after. Shortly after the vile social media posts began to boil over, and most long-time friends in that community, who had fallen prey to Marxist Leftism, turned their backs on me. In the space of a year, most everyone I had coached and loved now hated me.
Later, when Antifa thugs stole a young 350-pound pig, intending to behead her to “end all police violence,” I was called in to rescue her, which I did, after spending the night in my car alongside the Willamette River, protecting her from slaughter.
Some days after this, filming an Antifa protest along the waterfront, I was attacked by the thugs. Several men, faces hidden and clad in black surrounded me, bear spray aimed at my eyes. “She can film,” said someone next to me, “We have free speech.” The man with the bear spray replied, “Not in Portland you don’t.” In response, I raised my phone to shoot video. It was bashed from my hand. Soon after, a man battered me with an Antifa-issued shield and I was shoved and screamed at by gun-toting maniacs. Why? Because I stepped between the brutes and the Vietnam vet they were taunting. They knocked his cap off, were terrifying his wife, and I would not let that stand. So a mob of 15 or 20 of them attacked me. And yes, there’s video of all this. Here’s a frame from it:
After a few years, I thought I might be able to return to theater-making, and prepared to mount my adaptation of Macbeth, a three-hander curated to a swift 1:20 focusing on Mackers and Lady M titled The Macbeths, using Shakespeare’s language in such a way as to open out these characters in an explosive new form. This was a banger of a show, destined to do very well indeed. And then Portland Marxists decided I was not to be allowed to produce this play. They terrorized the theater space management, threatened all the artists associated with the show, and spewed their bile all over the internet. Of course they also threatened me, with Leftists promising to put posters up all over town with my photo and home address on them (“threatens bodily harm” – hate speech much?).
Two weeks from opening, the rental space capitulated and kicked me and my production out. Performers, designers, front of house, back of house, fight choreographer, hair and makeup… all out of a job. Oh, and a sexy article about all the drama was ginned up in the local left-wing rag, the Willamette Week, which seems to be the dubious “evidence” Mr. Zero brings to this conversation.
90 days after The Macbeths was shut down, I moved to Chapel Hill, North Carolina, running in fear for my life. Three thousand miles away, I again tried to make theater. But the Portland lunatics, with their Google alert on high and very little else to do with their lives, caught wind of it, reached out to the local acting community here, and – you guessed it – two weeks from opening a readers theater company, the performance space booted the project, having been terrorized into obedience. The place’s manager was embarrassed and deeply apologetic, telling me “You’d better watch out for them. They’re after you. They’re dangerous.”
I had been given a life sentence: I could never make art again. It was then, finally, that I considered suicide. I had hit rock bottom, nearly killed by the very same mindset that brings this charge to this union committee today.
Fortunately, I changed my mind and decided instead to devote my art to writing, and speaking, about the crime of artistic cancellation, in first person, as someone who lives it every day, with this charge, and this essay, a part of that work.
By the way, I am only one of thousands whose art is under assault. Former New York SAG-AFTRA board member Geoffrey Cantor, for example, directed October 7th, about the Hamas terror attacks. That play, its cast and crew, are now being attacked themselves by Marxist anti-Jewish activists, their play boycotted, with efforts underfoot to drive it from the Kennedy Center before it opens, using the same ghoulish means as they did to me.
This union is in the main a performing arts trade labor organization. It should protect me, not place me in danger, as it has done with this charge. And unless you have gone through it, you have no way. No way. Of understanding that this farce of a trial and everything that has come before it is a kind of soul murder, as Ibsen described it, and that to know that, for me to stand tall in the face of it, to retain my sanity and to find purpose after all that has been stolen from me – to speak out despite everything – is an act of bravery that none of my inquisitors will ever approach.
And that makes being charged with “conduct unbecoming” – against fearing for my life, being forced from my home state, facing suicide down and re-purposing my life from the ground up – a very small thing indeed.
The large thing, the thing that looms, is the Union abandoning its dictate to stand with its members, and to stand on the American principles that formed it.

Remember, the kinds of men that Portland thugs chant about with “Free-free, free Palestine!” slaughtered the cartoonists at Charlie Hebdo for their expression. One survivor, Laurent Sourisseau reminds us, “When you have something to say, there is always someone somewhere with a very good reason to stop you from saying it.” But the artists persevered, even in face of fanatic butchery. In this, I stand with Charlie. I stand where they fell.
And in fact, I stand where Charlie fell, too.
I’ve written about all this in The Art Thieves, Art from the Ashes, and The Artist in Exile.
Now, the law stands ready to address those who attempt to relieve citizens of their speech and sense of safety. I could apply it to those who’ve caused this loss of work and health, who terrified me with obscene phone calls and death threats, and who drove me out of Oregon to North Carolina, leaving everyone and everything behind. God knows I’ve kept receipts. But I won’t just yet. I’m glad to know, however, that FIRE has been busy defending people likewise attacked, and they have amassed an avalanche of case law for defenses similar to mine.
I have one more point to make in Act Two, and that is, how on earth did this union find it advisable to entertain this charge, and keep a straight face while doing so? Well, like so many trade labor unions – with the possible exception of the Teamsters under General President Sean O’Brien’s leadership – like the ACLU, the Southern Poverty Law Center, The American Federation of Teachers, most colleges and universities, the media and so on, SAG-AFTRA is a captured organization. Here’s proof.
Big picture: Let’s follow the money. From Capital Research Center: “In the 2024 election cycle alone, 95.45 percent of the union’s $12,895 in donations went to Democratic candidates, while only 2 percent was allocated to Republicans. Prior to that, in 2020, union members donated a total of $73,679 to congressional candidates, with 77.69 percent of those contributions supporting Democrats and 3.87 percent backing Republicans.” SAG-AFTRA is, for all intents and purposes, a Democrat.
The rest of the picture: The Union regularly platforms those members who serve as democratic mouthpieces like George Clooney and Robert De Niro, and spotlights people like Jane Fonda, with whom more than one Vietnam vet would like a word, so she can urge her fellow actors at the 2025 Screen Actors Guild Awards to “actively engage in social movements and oppose Trump’s policies…” Conversely, mention of conservative members in board meetings engenders scorn, and certainly none are ever center stage in Union representation.
As well, themes of Critical Theory pervade the website, as demonstrated at the linked document. Black Lives Matter, founded by Cullors and Garza, two trained Marxists with Cullors mentored by Eric Mann, a member of the terrorist Weather Underground of the 1960’s, was a huge part of the Union’s platform, starting in 2020. In addition, SAG-AFTRA, apparently unaware that land has regularly been taken by one tribe after another after another for centuries, in the most brutal ways imaginable going back to the Neanderthals, engages in the cringy humblebrag of land acknowledgement, which is coded Leftist behavior. (”SAG-AFTRA provides a formal land acknowledgment that is typically shared during its events and on significant holidays like Indigenous Peoples’ Day. The statement emphasizes the union’s commitment to honoring the ancestral stewards of the lands where its members live and work.”) The organization toyed with “Latinx” for a minute, and then like so many others, could no longer deny how ridiculous it sounded and quietly let it go; it still, however, insists that the twee term “sibling” be added to the grand tradition of the “brothers and sisters” appellation, in the misguided notion that a member could somehow be neither.
Top Union leadership has also declared, on the record, that the Union will not follow federal law regarding de-commissioning DEI efforts, and forced a vote affirming this from the board. There’s been pressure as well on National Board Zoom calls to include our pronouns where we list our name. And in those meetings, shows of bravado are made, declaring ICE shall never enter SAG-AFTRA’s doors (an event I frankly don’t ever see happening as I don’t think the organization is hiding someone in a supply closet somewhere inside the building), board members go on at length about the tyranny of this administration and the need to “take it to the streets,” on and on and on.
These comments have become so common that something like a quarter of our time is spent howling outrage and urging a public stance on social justice issues, with wages and working conditions last on the agenda.
And just yesterday at this writing, SAG-AFTRA sent out an anti-government “Member Alert,” which stated, in part, “It is the responsibility of our union to speak up when the lives and well-being of our members are threatened. There is simply no need for militarized intervention to carry out immigration policy. It is unacceptable for federal authorities to terrorize communities. The chaos and violence in Minnesota is abhorrent, and it must end.” The alert was signed by SAG-AFTRA President Sean Astin and National Executive Director Duncan Crabtree-Ireland.

But as members, we were not asked whether we supported federal immigration mandates, or approved this message. Not even the National Board was polled as to the wisdom, accuracy and appropriateness of sending it. Representing 160k members, SAG-AFTRA implied that every single member was in lockstep with the notice, and that simply cannot be true by the numbers.
The Union also claims to represent its 160k members in condemning the recent arrest of member Don Lemon following his unwelcome entry into St. Paul’s Cities Church, writing “The First Amendment protects this vital work, and any attempt to criminalize constitutionally protected journalism threatens not only our members but the fundamental democratic principle of a free press.” The organization handily ignores the pertinent bit that opens the First Amendment: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof…” and it has made a rush to judgement, rather than allow this nation of laws to engage in the process necessary to evaluate whether Lemon is an honest journalist or a domestic insurrectionist.

This rush has been seen before in the Union’s support for Jussie Smollett in 2019 — its statement on what was later revealed to be a fake hate crime read “Today’s reported attack on actor Jussie Smollett is a vicious and violent crime that cannot be tolerated. … We urge the Chicago authorities to move swiftly to identify, arrest and prosecute Mr. Smollett’s attackers and … We stand with Jussie Smollett, LGBTQ people and all marginalized communities in rejecting intolerance and brutality. An attack on one is an attack on all.” (The Illinois Supreme Court overturned Smollett’s eventual conviction, but it was because of a due process violation, not because it found him not guilty.) Given how that bit of playacting played out, it might have been wiser to have waited before screaming justice for Jussie, in much the same way a statement reading “SAG-AFTRA is aware of the arrest of journalist Don Lemon over recent events in St. Paul, Minnesota. The Union will be following legal proceedings closely and stands ready to support its member in all appropriate ways” might have been a better strategy.
Because the point here isn’t whether Lemon broke the law or not. That’s for the courts. The point is the Union, shrill on democracy when it suits, doesn’t see the dereliction of duty inherent in abandoning its work as a trade labor organization for Leftist causes; doesn’t care to know if any of its 160k members might object to its stance; and doesn’t care about the fallout from the deal it has made with the devil to devolve into a monoculture obsessed with Critical Theory-based Marxism, to denounce any member with a counter viewpoint, and to endanger all members in its lack of real care.
The Union, driven not by the members but by a very few people in top leadership, is being used as a cudgel, a sledgehammer for the Leftist activism that has overtaken it.
We will touch only briefly on the damage that all this emphasis on Leftist politics has done to our members’ bank accounts. Their work opportunities have plummeted with the Hollywood machine breaking down. Audiences are fleeing woke “entertainment” in droves; everyone knows it, including the Union, but since the goal is not to entertain but to dismantle the American experiment, it’s a price this occupied institution is willing to pay. This writer makes clear the reason why: “The problem with Hollywood movies of late is what Critical Drinker calls THE MESSAGE. It goes something like this — we in Hollywood believe we have THE ANSWER and now we’re going to instruct you on how you should see the world, masculinity, sexuality, issues of race. The themes are all the same – they reflect the platform of the Democratic Party and express only that point of view.”
Hell, I explained all this quite plainly in an essay in 2021, but no one listened, and today the Union’s members reap the bitter harvest.
“So if you do win an award tonight, don’t use it as a platform to make a political speech. You’re in no position to lecture the public about anything. You know nothing about the real world. Most of you spent less time in school than Greta Thunberg. So if you win, come up, accept your little award, thank your agent and your God, and fuck off.” — Ricky Gervais, giving advice the Union should take seriously.
Now, I let all this nonsense at the Union slide, because, you know, free speech, even if I found it idiotic at best and dangerous, possibly a violation of labor law at worst. I just hoped that eventually it would pass. Then my own free speech was attacked by Mr. Zero, abetted by this fallen union, and I was called to respond.
So we have to ask ourselves, why is this worth all the effort? This is one member, defending herself on a Zoom call opposite a small but powerful committee – even given the likelihood of this charge dying a’borning, why go to all this trouble and cost to go through the motions of what will inevitably fail, heartily disappointing Mr. Zero and the Portland Leftists behind all this?
After all, unlike my case, I have direct evidence of separate charges against Sean Combs, Jussie Smollett, and five other union members brought to the National Board that the Union refused to bring forward to this Disciplinary Committee. The organization rejected them, responding every time, “After carefully reviewing the pertinent evidence and deliberating at length, and with particular reference to union members’ rights under the Landrum-Griffin Act ... there is not sufficient basis to conclude that there has been a violation of Article XIV of the SAG-AFTRA Constitution. Given the absence of probable cause, your charge will not be referred to a Disciplinary Committee.”

And setting aside the selective application of the charge of conduct unbecoming, the Union is equally selective when it comes to ignoring unbecoming conduct. Neither charges, a revocation of union membership, nor public condemnation were visited upon union member Bill Cosby when he was found guilty of sexual assault, nor member Danny Masterson for his rape conviction. Though SAG-AFTRA castigated Kanye West for his anti-Semitic comments, the Union did not bring him in for discipline. And rather than chastise, it rushed to the defense of Jimmy Kimmel when Charlie Kirk was murdered, and the talk show host joked about the assassination a few hours after that bloodbath.
In fact, freedom for a member to mock a young father’s live-on-campus slaughter was rabidly protected by the Union, along with defending the rights of members to call President Trump a “sociopathic, psychopathic, malignant narcissist” (De Niro); a “xenophobic fascist” (Clooney); a “racist, abusive coward” (Don Cheadle); and any number of slander-adjacent insults. But after January 6th and the ruckus at the Capital, the Union did, in its wisdom, vote to plunk Donald Trump squarely in front of the Disciplinary Committee, to defend himself against “probable cause of a violation of SAG-AFTRA’s Constitution.” In response, Trump resigned, after which the Union permanently banned him from ever rejoining.
I have no objection to these members’ opinions, and I support their right to them, as does the Union, clearly.
I wonder why it doesn’t support mine?
I think it’s because I’m not just “one member.” I’m an outspoken one challenging the party line, and one with the ability to influence hearts and minds at that. I’m an example.
This move, right out of Mao’s playbook, is to show anyone paying attention what happens to free thinkers, to heterodox speakers. “Look what they did to her” is the hoped-for reaction. “Let’s keep our heads down,” is the whispered reply.
So when the board veers into the political, as it should not do; when members declare the revolution is now, man, and that the Union must join it; when the “right” politicians are lionized and the “wrong” ones demonized; when not one single thought is given to the fact that, statistically speaking, it is impossible that everyone in the room is in agreement with the partisan sentiments expressed and that no thought, none at all, is given to the divergent opinions of others; then in fact the goal is to scare everyone not toeing the party line into silence, with this message: Say one word in opposition to the blatant left-wing politics of this supposedly democratic organization. One word. And we will shame you, shun you, burn your reputation at the social media stake, impact your finances, steal your sense of wellbeing, and, in this case, try to kick you to the curb after 38 years’ service. Shame. For shame.
The ploy here, you see, is to teach those watching to take the knee, or suffer the consequences. Certainly it is a stark message to me to shut the hell up. But I will not kneel. This will not work.
We mustn’t allow our speech to be chilled in seemingly oh-so-virtuous increments as this one pretends to be. That way, step by small step, lies loss of liberty, and an enshackled future. Our friend James Madison reminds us why we must shove back, and hard: “There are more instances of the abridgment of the freedom of the people by gradual and silent encroachments of those in power than by violent and sudden usurpations.” He was right then, and he’s right now.
Look. The stark truth is, this charge is completely political in nature and designed to retaliate and intimidate. This is only about free speech: who has it, and whether they may be deprived of it. Based on the US Constitution, SAG-AFTRA’s Constitution, and the Landrum-Griffin act, I have it, and I may not be deprived of it. It’s equally plain to see why the Union’s made the stupid mistake of entertaining this attempt, an effort as predictable as its failure to succeed at it will be.
I hope I’ve made my case in this regard, and I thank the Committee for its time.
This concludes my defense.
ACT THREE – “THERE ARE FAR, FAR BETTER THINGS AHEAD THAN ANY WE LEAVE BEHIND.” – C.S. Lewis
This is not an easy exercise, but it is a good one, I think. The American project, which is what is under attack here, is a miracle unseen in history until a scant 250 years ago. As we move through our daily activities, I think it’s possible to forget what we have here: our freedoms, our devotion to protecting them and to helping other countries achieve them, or regain them when they are lost. That course-correction is built into our system and that with it, America can continue to bend toward justice; to protect its citizens from harm from within and without; and to continue to be the land of opportunity that so many from all over the world seek to either enter, or emulate.
I think it’s possible that as we forget, and fall to the false promises of Marxism, which this charge against me articulates, we weaken the foundation this project stands upon, and we ensure a future of nothing but rubble: empty, bleak, and devoid of the magnificent promise our country held. The shining city will fall dark.
And that brings me to the second reason for being glad to be here, which I mentioned in Act One. Here it is, and it’s a two-parter.
First, because I welcome and embrace any opportunity to be challenged on this subject; to face any nervousness I might reasonably have around circumstances like the one I find myself in today. I am thankful and grateful that God has put me here, in this fire, to be further tempered, in the same way I am grateful he took so much away from me, so I could finally do the job I am here to do. No play, no coaching, no voice gig compares to it, and I cannot believe the good fortune that left me bereft, and made me rich.
Second, I relish learning the lesson – yet again – that there is absolutely nothing you can do to hurt me. No decision, no persecution, no repercussions, no retaliation, no intimidation, no attacks upon my good name or reputation; you can take nothing away from me that I don’t freely give.
You know, funny thing: Charges were brought against me, Paul Reggio and Diane McBain back in 2000. Just imagine – a quarter of a century ago. We were known, interestingly, as the Free Speech Three.
The charges were spurious – alleged was a breach of confidentiality – and they were brought by political opponents who sought to reduce our influence in the contentious commercial negotiations and strike of ’99-‘00. They were dropped, as this Dave McNary article reports, as I knew they would be. But once I had been run through that grisly abattoir, I began to lose fear of standing in the public square and declaring the truth in full voice.
The years since have hardened my steel to the sticking place.
And thanks to the US Constitution, to the SAG-AFTRA Constitution, and to the Landrum-Griffin Act, I have a right to my voice, my thoughts, words and deeds. I also have an obligation to protect your rights well past any positions I hold on any subject, and above any injury you may cause me via your determination as to this charge.
But I may not, no never, allow an attempted infringement on my freedom of speech go unchallenged. So I must remind the SAG-AFTRA Disciplinary Committee and the Union: Free speech is protected under several laws and a Constitutional Article. Paraphrasing, my inquisitor has requested this committee to do the right thing, not the safe thing. I’m requiring it to do the legal thing.
So dear brothers and sisters, investigate the charge, take from me what you will, or let the rights promised me by the Founders stand.
A small caution, though, as we conclude: Do not mistake in me what might look like some measure of grace at best or grim determination at worst. This relentless savagery has been and remains an abiding wound. Though the Marxists failed to convince me to kill myself (others have, by the way – killed themselves because of Leftists’ wilding) I know it has taken years off my life. It has been a thief of joy. This journey has been terrifying, with the endless hounding, dark threats, and beastly persecution from people like Mr. Zero.
But do you remember, way back before Disney shoved itself to the brink of bankruptcy with its Marxist programming, in Fantasia, when Mickey as the Sorcerer’s Apprentice tried to get out of his chores by replicating the broom and bucket, and it very quickly got very out of hand? If you convict me, you’re just going to make more brooms and buckets. So there is solace in the loss, and something to be gained.
Finally, when it comes to the challenge and cost of this work – here’s that Bible bit I promised you – I’m comforted by my faith, by affirmations like this interrogation, and by men like Isiah, who, after God asks in Isiah 6:8, “Whom shall I send, and who will go for us?” says, “Here am I; send me!”
Bless you all, and God Bless America.
“COURAGE IS NOT SIMPLY ONE OF THE VIRTUES, BUT THE FORM OF EVERY VIRTUE AT THE TESTING POINT.” – C.S. Lewis
I did not end the original essay with this poem and song, but I’ll finish up this version with two favorites. Thanks for reading.
Eternal Justice
The man is thought a knave, or fool, Or bigot, plotting crime, Who, for the advancement of his kind, Is wiser than his time. For him the hemlock shall distil; For him the axe be bared; For him the gibbet shall be built; For him the stake prepared. Him shall the scorn and wrath of men Pursue with deadly aim; And malice, envy, spite, and lies, Shall desecrate his name. But Truth shall conquer at the last, For round and round we run; And ever the Right comes uppermost, And ever is Justice done. Pace through thy cell, old Socrates, Cheerily to and fro; Trust to the impulse of thy soul, And let the poison flow. They may shatter to earth the lamp of clay That holds a light divine, But they cannot quench the fire of thought By any such deadly wine. They cannot blot thy spoken words From the memory of man By all the poison ever was brewed Since time its course began. To-day abhorred, to-morrow adored, For round and round we run, And ever the Truth comes uppermost, And ever is Justice done. Plod in thy cave, gray anchorite; Be wiser than thy peers; Augment the range of human power, And trust to coming years. They may call thee wizard, and monk accursed, And load thee with dispraise; Thou wert born five hundred years too soon For the comfort of thy days; But not too soon for human kind. Time hath reward in store; And the demons of our sires become The saints that we adore. The blind can see, the slave is lord, So round and round we run; And ever the Wrong is proved to be wrong And ever is Justice done. Keep, Galileo, to thy thought, And nerve thy soul to bear; They may gloat o’er the senseless words they wring From the pangs of thy despair; They may veil their eyes, but they cannot hide The sun’s meridian glow; The heel of a priest may tread thee down And a tyrant work thee woe; But never a truth has been destroyed; They may curse it and call it crime; Pervert and betray, or slander and slay Its teachers for a time. But the sunshine aye shall light the sky, As round and round we run; And the Truth shall ever come uppermost, And Justice shall be done. And live there now such men as these-- With thoughts like the great of old? Many have died in their misery, And left their thought untold; And many live, and are ranked as mad, And are placed in the cold world’s ban, For sending their bright, far-seeing souls Three centuries in the van. They toil in penury and grief, Unknown, if not maligned; Forlorn, forlorn, bearing the scorn Of the meanest of mankind! But yet the world goes round and round, And the genial seasons run; And ever the Truth comes uppermost, And ever is Justice done.
Charles Mackay 1814–1889
I think Charles Mackay would approve this song.






















I'm glad you were exonerated, but I am not surprised. No one I know - and I mean NO ONE - took the conduct unbecoming charges seriously at all. It is a fact that, once filed, the charges must be adjudicated per the union constitution - much like election challenges - but it was nothing out of the ordinary in that scenario.
Again, I'm glad the tempest has left the teapot and we can now use it for its intended purpose - a nice spot of tea.
Crumpet?
Oh Mary, I'm feeling overwhelmed just READING it all... I can only imagine how broken you're feeling living through it. I wish I could give you a big long silent HUG. Imagine a virtual Hug... even though they suck.No words. You've heard enough words. I'll turn my words privately upwards... into Prayers. Continued Prayers... for Healing and Recovery; Renewed Strength and NEW sense of Purpose.... "Out of the Ashes, we Rise"... into NEW LIFE. ❤️🙏✝️🙏